Hi folks,
I have a '17 BRZ with PP, and recently started looking for aftermarket wheels.
To my disappointment, it turned out that those Brembos are so big that many wheels don't fit.
On top of that, the available information about what fits was scarce. I even ended up ordering wheels that didn't fit — because I couldn't easily find any information that they don't 
I've decided to gather a list of known FIT (without spacers! 5x100 only), as well as popular DO NOT FIT wheels for these calipers. This list is combined from an old post by FT86SpeedFactory (thanks for the starting point!) and some random posts on this forum I've found.
Feel free to post specs of wheels not on this list that clear PP Brembos (preferably with photo evidence that they clear) and I'll try my best to keep this list up to date for a while. Also please share if you know of some wheels that do not fit that might be of common interest (RPF1 17x9, I'm looking at you!).
BRZ PP seems to have the same calipers as BRZ tS and 2004–2017 STi, this can be a good lead for more finds.
Also attached is a template for "Brembo 1H4.6005A" you can use to check fitment. I believe it's for the "Brembo GT" calipers, not PP calipers, and Brembo GT's are known to be wider than PP. My understanding is that anything that fits Brembo GT should also fit PP, but I'm not 100% sure.
This list is focused mostly on clearing the brake calipers.
For other fitment questions (will it fit? will it poke? will it rub? will it hit the strut? etc.) it generally doesn't matter if you have Brembos or base trim brakes, so there should be more information on that on this forum, such as in the first three posts in this thread.
Don't forget to use your own judgement before making a purchase — I'm just collecting what I find online, and I can't personally verify every combo / claim.
Note that if one variation of the wheel is listed here as FIT, it doesn't guarantee that another variation will fit too, e.g. it's not uncommon for wider wheels to have more concave spokes than narrower wheels of the same model, causing issues on the hub-side edge of the caliper.
Enough boilerplate, enjoy the list!
In alphabetical order:
720Form
GTF1 17x8.0 +35 DO NOT FIT
GTF1 17x9.0 +35 DO NOT FIT (6 mm spacer might be enough)
949 Racing
6UL 17x8.0 (offset?) DO NOT FIT
6UL 17x9.0 +40 FIT
Advan / Yokohama
TC III 18x9.5 +45 FIT
TC4 18x9.5 +45 FIT
Advanti DST
Storm S1 17x8.0 +35 barely fit, probably need a 3 mm spacer
Ambit
RE02 17x9.0 +35 FIT EVIDENCE/PHOTOS NEEDED!
RS18 18x9.5 +38 FIT
Aodhan Wheels
AH02 18x9.5 +30 FIT, but a bit tight
DS02 18x9.5 +35 probably need a 5 mm spacer
APEX
ARC-8 17x9.0 +42 FIT but some tires may have issues with stock suspension
EC-7R 17x9.5 +40 FIT
EC-7R 18x9.5 +40 FIT
EC-7R other sizes almost certainly fit
AVID.1
AV-20 17x8.0 +35 FIT
AV-20 18x9.5 +38 FIT
Barracuda
Karizzma 18x8.0 +38 FIT?
BBS
RF504 17x7.5 +48 FIT, might want to use ~2-3 mm spacer
RG345 17x7.0 +48 FIT
Cosmis Racing
MR7 18x9.0 +25 FIT
R1 18x9.5 +35 FIT
XT-005R 18x9.0 +25 probably fit? MORE EVIDENCE/PHOTOS NEEDED!
DAI
DW100, 17x7.5 +42 FIT
Drag
DR-38 17x9.0 +38 FIT
Enkei
PF01 17x7.5 +45 FIT
PF01 17x8.0 +35 FIT
PF01 18x8.5 +45 FIT
PF05 17x9.0 +40 FIT
PF05 17x8.5 +48 should fit? EVIDENCE/PHOTOS NEEDED!
PF05 18x9.0 +42 (?) FIT
Raijin 18x8.5 +45 FIT
RPF1 17x8.0 +45 FIT (note that they have convex spokes for the 8" wide variant)
RPF1 17x8.0 +35 FIT (note that they have convex spokes for the 8" wide variant)
RPF1 17x9.0 +35 DO NOT FIT (need 8 mm spacer, but even then sit too tight)
RPF1 17x9.0 +45 DO NOT FIT (more info welcome)
RPF1 18x8.0 +35 FIT
T6S 18x8.0 +45 barely fit, probably need a 3+ mm spacer
TFR 17x8.0 +45 FIT
TS-5 17x8.0 +45 FIT
TS9 17x8.0 +45 FIT
TS9 17x9.0 +45 FIT but a 5 mm spacer is recommended
TS9 18x8.5 +45 FIT
TS-10 17x8.0 +45 FIT
TS-10 18x8.0 +45 FIT
TS-V 17x8.0 +45 barely fit, probably need a 3 mm spacer
ESR
SR05 18x10.5 +22 FIT
Fast Wheels
FC04 17x8.0 +35 FIT
FC04 17x8.0 +40 FIT
Focal
F20 17x8.0 +42 probably FIT EVIDENCE/PHOTOS NEEDED!
Gram Lights / Rays
57CR 17x9.0 +38 FIT (might want a 1–2 mm spacer)
57CR 18x9.5 +38 FIT
57DR 17x9.0 +38 FIT
57DR 18x9.5 +38 FIT
57Transcend 17x7.0 +42 require 5mm spacers?
57XTC 18x9.5 +38 FIT
57Xtreme 18x8.5 +42 DO NOT FIT (fit with 12 mm spacers)
57Xtreme 18x9.5 +40 FIT the brakes but DON'T CLEAR STOCK STRUTS
57Xtreme 18x9.5 +35 FIT
GTS
GTS G709 18x8.0 +35 FIT
JNC
JNC002 18x9.5 +35 FIT
JNC030 17x9.0 +30 FIT
Kansei
Corsa 18x9.0 +35 FIT
Konig
Ampliform 17x8.0 +40 DO NOT FIT, will require 5 mm spacer or even more
Ampliform 17x9.0 +40 FIT
Dekagram 17x8.0 +40 DO NOT FIT (5 mm spacer might be enough)
Dekagram 17x9.0 +40 FIT
Hypergram 17x8.0 +40 barely fit, probably need a 3 mm spacer
Hypergram 17x9.0 +40 FIT
Hypergram 18x8.5 +38 FIT might need a thin spacer (more photos)
Ultraform 17x8.0 +40 DO NOT FIT (5 mm spacer might be enough)
Kosei
K4R 17x8.0 +36 FIT
Mach V
Awesome 17x9.0 +42 FIT EVIDENCE/PHOTOS NEEDED!
Crucial 18x9.5 +42 FIT
Wicked Awesome 18x9.5 +42 FIT EVIDENCE/PHOTOS NEEDED!
Mak
Rapide 18x8.0 +35 FIT?
Veloce 17x7.0 +48 DO NOT FIT (need ~12.5 mm spacers)
Method
MR502 17x8.0 +38 FIT
MOMO
Heritage 6 17x9.0 +35 FIT
Motegi Racing
MR140 18x8.5 +45 FIT
Option Lab Wheels
R716 18x9.5 +35 FIT
R716 18x8.5 +40 FIT
OZ
Ultraleggera 17x8.0 +48 FIT
Ultraleggera 17x8.0 +35 FIT
Ultraleggera 18x8.0 +48 FIT
Prodrive
GC-06H 18x8.0 +43 FIT
GT1 18x7.5 +48 SNUG fit
Rota
G-Force 17x8.0 +48 seem to FIT
KB-F 18x8.5 +44 FIT
Titan 17x8.0 +?? DO NOT FIT EVIDENCE/PHOTOS NEEDED!
Titan 17x9.0 +35 FIT EVIDENCE/PHOTOS NEEDED!
Titan 17x9.0 +42 likely DO NOT FIT (need 3 mm spacers, might as well just get +35)
Rotiform
BLQ 18x8.5 +35 FIT
KPS 18x8.5 +35 FIT
KPS 18x9.5 +45 DO NOT FIT (need 3 mm spacers)
Sparco
Assetto Gara 17x7.5 +35 FIT
Trofeo 5 17x7.5 +48 FIT
SSR
GTV02 18x8.5 +44 probably FIT, confirmation with Brembos would be great
GTX01 17x7.0 +50 likely DO NOT FIT
GTX01 17x8.0 +45 FIT, photo evidence would be great
GTX01 17x9.0 +38 FIT
GTX01 18x7.5 +48 likely DO NOT FIT
GTX01 18x8.5 +44 FIT, photo evidence would be great
GTX01 18x9.5 +40 FIT, photo evidence would be great
Speedline
Type 2013C 18x8.0 +48 FIT, confirmation with Brembos would be great
Type 2110 17x8.0 +48 probably FIT
Turini Type 2120 17x8.0 +40 FIT
Turini Type 2120 17x8.0 +48 FIT
Turini Type 2120 17x9.0 +40 FIT, confirmation with Brembos would be great
Turini Type 2120 18x8.0 +48 probably FIT
Speedwell
RS-1 18x9.5 +45 DO NOT FIT need a spacer and probably don't clear stock struts
RS-R 18x9.5 +40 FIT the brakes but DON'T CLEAR STOCK STRUTS
Subaru
non-PP BRZ wheels 17x7 +48 DO NOT FIT
2017+ BRZ PP wheels 17x7.5 +48 FIT (obviously)
2022 BRZ Premium 17x7.5 +48 FIT but 3mm spacer is recommended
2022 BRZ Limited 18x7.5 +48 SHOULD FIT, photos would be welcome
2004 STI 5x100 17x7.5 +53 FIT but see details
2011–2014 WRX wheels 17x8.0 +53 DO NOT FIT, need 3 mm spacers
2007-2008 Liberty GT SpecB Tuned by STI Enkei 18x7.5 +55 (part #ST2810021020, ST2810021030) FIT
2004 JDM Forester STI Enkei 18x8.0 +48 FIT
V7 STI ??? FIT
Superspeed
RF03RR 18x9.5 +38 DO NOT FIT need 3+ mm spacer
Titan 7
T-R10 18x9.5 +40 FIT
T-S5 17x9.0 +37 FIT
T-S5 18x9.5 +40 FIT
Toyota
2022 GR86 Base 17x7.5 +48 FIT but 3mm spacer is recommended
TRD
TRD Forged 17x7.5 +43 FIT
TRD 18x7.5 +35 may fit if those TRD calipers are the same size as PP Brembos — need more evidence.
TSW
Bathurst 17x8.0 +35 FIT
Interlagos 18x8.0 +35 FIT
Nurburgring 17x8.0 +45 FIT
Nurburgring 18x8.0 +45 likely FIT, more evidence welcome
TWS
T66-F 18x8.5 +42 FIT
T66-F 18x9.5 +45 FIT
VarrsToen
ES6 18x9.5 +35 FIT but might be too close
Vision
Cross 17x7.5 +40 FIT
Volk Racing
CE28N 18x9.5 +38 FIT EVIDENCE/PHOTOS NEEDED!
Volk CE28SL 17x7.5 +48 FIT
G25 18x8.0 +45 FIT more evidence welcome
G25 19x9.0 +45 FIT more evidence welcome -- wait, do such wheels even exist?
TE37 17x8.0 +40 LIKELY NEED 3mm spacer
TE37 18x9.5 +36 FIT
TE37 18x9.5 +40 FIT
ZE40 18x7.5 +48 DO NOT FIT (need 5+ mm spacer)
ZE40 17x8.0 +47 DO NOT FIT
ZE40 18x8.0 +45 FIT
WedsSports
TC105N 17x8.0 +42 FIT According to CSG, the clearance is minimal, so you might want to use a 3 mm spacer. EVIDENCE/PHOTOS NEEDED!
TC105N 17x9.0 +35 FIT
TC105N 18x9.5 +38 FIT
TC105X 17x8.0 +42 FIT According to CSG, the clearance is minimal, you might want to use a 3 mm spacer.
TC105X 17x9.0 +35 FIT
TC105X 18x8.5 +43 might fit, EVIDENCE NEEDED though!
SA-10R 18x8.5 +45 FIT
SA-10R 18x9.5 +40 FIT EVIDENCE/PHOTOS NEEDED!
SA-10R 18x9.5 +45 FIT the brakes but DON'T CLEAR STOCK STRUTS
WORK Wheels
CR Kiwami Ultimate 17x9.0 +38 FIT
Meister S1 3P 18x10.5 +14 FIT
Yoshihara
D-12C 18x8.0 +40 DO NOT FIT
XXR
527 17x9.75 +25 FIT
550 18x8.75 +36 FIT
Thanks to timurrrr